Before I dive into this controversy, let me make one thing clear: I think Spongebob Squarepants is weird and irritating. But that has nothing to do with his sexual orientation.
The hyperactive cartoon character, a talking sponge who lives under the sea in a pineapple, has come under fire recently from the ultra-conservative group, Focus on the Family, for promoting "acceptance of homosexuality to children." Spongebob was among a slew of other cartoon characters and Muppets featured in a diversity video that was sent out to 60,000 American elementary schools this week.
This is not the first time the far right has called into question the sexual leanings of fictional children's characters. A few years back, Reverend Jerry Falwell attacked Tinky Winky from the Teletubbies for being a gay role model. Why Reverend Falwell was watching Teletubbies in the first place is beyond me. He's got to be old enough for Mr. Rogers by now.
There's been speculation for years about Ernie and Bert. (When I blogged about them last weekend, I was unaware of the Spongebob controversy.) And I also learned recently that Noddy and Big Ears, folk heroes to British school children, and the star characters in my third grade Christmas pantomime when I lived in England, never made it in the US because, according to the BBC they were believed by some Americans to be "implicitly homosexual." Noddy and Big Ears were an elf and a talking toy.
How people find time to worry about the sexual lives of elves, toys, Muppets, and Teletubbies is something I find baffling. Have they considered getting a hobby? But the latest Spongebob controversy strikes me as especially absurd. It is scientifically impossible for a sponge to be gay.
To make sure I was not making false assumptions, I called my friend Darbi, who almost got a Bachelor's Degree in marine biology a few years back, but opted for the more lucritive field of English instead. Darbi confirmed for me some information that will shock scientists worldwide: I, Dave Fox, actually retained one small scrap of information from my high school biology class.
The piece of information I miraculously retained has to do with the sexual habits of sea sponges. Sponges cannot be gay, or straight, or bisexual, or transvestite. Sea sponges have no gender. They have no sex organs. They are just sponges.
"But they reproduce, right?" I asked Darbi.
Yes, she said, but in a boring, non-kinky kind of way. They don't whip out the handcuffs and have hot, steamy sponge sex. Darbi told me she thinks sponges can actually reproduce with themselves.
Boy, there's a scary thought. What if masturbation made you pregnant? But sponges apparently can't even do that. They just simply have no sexuality.
So the media have had a field day with this one, attacking Focus on the Family's founder James Dobson for speculating about Spongebob's sexual orientation. FotF has responded with a scathing rebuttal, stating Dr. Dobson never said Spongebob was a gay sponge. All he said, their article asserts, is that the video in question was promoting tolerance for homosexuality, which Dr. Dobson believes is immoral.
Fair enough. Dr. Dobson has a right to his moral views just like everybody else in this country. But he goes on to attack mainstream media outlets, such as MSNBC, charging, "I have never had my words more misrepresented than they were in this instance."
Did the mainstream media misrepresent Dr. Dobson? Probably. I don't believe Dobson ever actually said Spongebob Squarepants was gay. But as a professional humor writer, I can't be upset with columnists who allowed themselves a little poetic license here. When radicals on either side of the spectrum start getting their panties in a bunch over sex and cartoon characters, they're feeding us with material.
Here's the real kicker though: In a desperate attempt to defend itself, Focus on the Family is now accusing MSNBC columnist Michael Ventre of saying that Christians are "creepy, rigid, arrogant, cruel, know-it-all, pompous, obnoxious and treacherous -- better know by the acronym CRACKPOT."
Ventre did use those words, but not in regard to all Christians, as FotF implies. What Ventre said was that radical conservative groups are hijacking Christianity, and that those fringe people are "giving Jesus Christ a bad name."
So, Dr. Dobson, you have every right to attack the media if they have distorted your statements -- but distorting theirs does not help your case.
When I started blogging about this incident, my plan was to slam Dr. Dobson for claiming Spongebob Squarepants was gay. I now do believe that Dobson said no such thing. And there is something else I believe.
I believe so-called "pro-family" groups like Focus on the Family are making bigger asses of themselves every day for taking on topics like this in the first place. I don't feel sorry for them for the firestorm of ridicule they attract with these issues. I believe they are scared. They are losing ground -- because in 2005, far more Americans have a problem with FotF's message of intolerance than we do with people of minority sexual orientations.
Recent Comments